Hoshizora no Memoria Review

April 22, 2009 at 3:38 pm 22 comments

hm_title_screen

Company: FAVORITE
Game site: 星空のメモリア -Wish upon a shooting star-
Release date: March 27, 2009
Links: Getchu, walkthrough, seiyuu listing

Hoshizora no Memoria is the most recent game by FAVORITE, which is associated with CROSSNET of Maple Colors fame. Hoshizora is a fantasy ADV about school life and the stars, as the title suggests. The game is full of stories about everything about the universe and ties it in with family and love relationships.

Make sure you patch the game before you start playing. Patching the game to ver1.1 will erase your save files.

Opening Theme

I cannot stop raving about this OP. It’s catchy, flashy, introduces the characters well and best of all, the animation actually matches the beat of the song. It’s one of the best I’ve seen in this year.

Scenario

変わらない星空の下で、俺たちは変わっていく──
流れ星に願った夢、叶えようとしてますか──?

Kogasaka You returns to his hometown of Hibarigasaki in the north, where the stars can be seen clearly in the night sky. Seven years ago, he had made a promise at the observatory with a girl he had met that they will be reunited some day, just like Orihime and Hikoboshi in the legend of Tanabata. Arriving at the observatory, he meets a shinigami named Mare who had been waiting for him. As he reminisces about his childhood promise, she tells him to close his eyes just like the girl from the past had asked him to. Suddenly, she hits him with her scythe and says that he can move on with his life now that his nightmare is gone.

hm_cg4

「これで、あなたの悪夢は、ひとつ刈られた」

There are 5 initial routes to Hoshizora, plus a true end (***) and another end for Mare. Kosame’s route is opened after completing Komomo’s, while Chinami’s route is opened after completing Isuzu’s. Completing all 5 routes will open up the final two routes. Kosame and Mare routes were really short. Mare seems like a short bonus route (for some loli loving), but it also serves a purpose in explaining the title. The true end is most definitely worth completing the other routes for. The ending is one of the best and most satisfying I’ve read.

The scenarios in Hoshizora revolve around resolving relationship problems and depicting character growth. There are distinct parallels with Greek and Japanese myths about the stars, the moon and other celestial bodies, and there are plenty of scientific explanations as well. The notion of wishing upon a shooting star is a prominent basis for Hoshizora.

The common route (first two weeks of the game) is extremely long. Even if you skip through it on subsequent playthroughs, it will take over half an hour. It introduces each of the stories, however I believe it is longer than needed. There were also various repeated scenarios which were funny the first time, but got a bit annoying in subsequent renditions. I’m looking at you, Chinami.

To tell the stories, we’re treated to flashbacks and changing perspectives, so you can see what happened in the past as well as what everyone is feeling. The game tries to explain everything and the information is placed across multiple routes, which is sometimes confusing. I feel that they could’ve structured the plot a bit better so it doesn’t feel so disjointed. However, in general, I found the stories enjoyable. I appreciated the representation of clubs and school life, the various astronomical references (scientific and mythological), as well as the light comedy. It reminded me of stories about the stars that I heard of back when I was small.

hm_cg

Personally, I feel ***’s route was by far the best. The thing about the stories in the game is that it’s less about furthering the romantic relationships with each girl as becoming a support for them to solve their own problems. Along the way, you don’t only learn about the main heroines, but also about all the subcharacters. That’s why I liked Chinami and Komomo’s routes a lot. Asuho’s was fine, but everything was related to her and seemed a bit shallow. Isuzu’s story was a total mess until the final third. Mare and Kosame’s stories left me disappointed due to their length. It may be partially because their routes overlapped a lot with *** and Komomo’s routes.

It would be great if there’s an addition to the game that resolves some of the stories for the subcharacters. I feel that there were a bunch of minor loose threads that haven’t been tied up. It was a bit mind boggling how some subcharacters only showed up for a scene or two and then never showed up again. I want to know more about them!

I wonder if the town of Hibarigasaki is based on the town of Otaru in Hokkaido. I’ve visited this quaint coastal town a few years ago and many of the places that show up in the game also exist there, such as a canal, a planetarium, an observatory on a hill overlooking  the town, a Shinto shrine and an orgel (music box) shop. It’s a great place to visit if you get the chance.

Micchi’s recommended route order:
Asuho, Komomo, Isuzu, Kosame, Chinami, ***, Mare

Micchi’s route rankings:
***, Chinami, Komomo, Asuho, Isuzu, Mare, Kosame

Characters

Kogasaka You

The protagonist of the game… that’s You! All kidding aside, You used to live in Hibarigasaki, but he moved to the city 7 years ago. He came back to Hibarigasaki after the death of his mother and now lives with his aunt Shino and his sister Chinami. Very protective of Chinami. He sometimes pushes himself to do too much and doesn’t rely on others. He had made a promise with a girl at the observatory that they will meet again some day.

What an annoying name when written in romaji. Even though he’s bakabaka and damedame, he’s not totally useless. We learn more about his past as more routes are played. It was quite satisfying to see his character grow. Unfortunately, I can’t find any pics of him that weren’t spoilers.

hm_asuho

Minahoshi Asuho

You’s classmate and the class rep. She’s also the deputy leader of the stargazing circle (shortened to 天クル). She helps out at her father’s cafe, Milky Way. Loves the stars a lot and names everything on the menu in the cafe after star-based myths even if there is no resemblance whatsoever. Asuho is really friendly and a good mood-maker. However, when it comes to love and relationships, she is very shy and reserved, almost to the point where she doesn’t have much confidence.

I loooooooooove Asuho! While some people find her childish and annoying, I absolutely adore her liveliness and when she turns totally dere and is like a small puppy clinging on to you, she’s irresistable! Not to mention she’s a great cook too! Hau~ omochikaeri~!

hm_komomo

Hisakaki Komomo

With blonde hair and twintails, Mokomoko Komomo is the tsundere of the game. She is the older Hisakaki twin. Komomo’s on the student council and is a serious-minded and honest person, although she comes off as tough and stubborn to others. She tends to try to do everything by herself. Hates the stars and doesn’t like to be called by her name.

I personally don’t like tsunderes much, so Komomo’s my least favourite character. If you like tsunderes, you’ll appreciate her dere side more than I did.

hm_isuzu

Aoi Isuzu

Isuzu is one year younger than You and lives next door to him and Chinami. She looks like a cute kouhai and is treated like a small animal, but she has a sharp tongue and can be very rude. As a result, she doesn’t make friends easily. She has a younger sister, Suzuha.

Her rudeness puts me off and it doesn’t really get much better. Of course, there’s a reason to it all, but I wished she wasn’t as rude. I feel as if her character didn’t develop as much as other characters.

hm_kosame

Hisakaki Kosame

Komame Kosame is the younger twin sister of Komomo and often engages in yuri acts with her in public. She’s much more mild mannered than Komomo. Always says the right thing at the right time. She likes teasing her friends (Asuho) at times. Doesn’t like talking about herself.

I liked Kosame. She would make a nice girlfriend. It’s too bad her route did her no justice.

hm_chinami

Kogasaka Chinami

You’s younger sister. Fails at pretty much everything and extremely clingy and annoying. A master chef: anything she cooks turns black. A true troublemaker. However, she does have an uncanny ability to make friends. Her serious and depressed side is a polar opposite.

I generally love imoutos, but Chinami annoyed me so much I almost couldn’t get through the end of the first game day. After finishing her route, my view didn’t change. However, if she wasn’t chattering and causing trouble nonstop, she’s actually decent.

hm_mare1

Mare S. Ephemeral

A shinigami that waited for You at the observatory. She doesn’t talk much and acts cool, but is actually a crybaby. Mare carries a scythe, but it is used to cull nightmares, not lives. She mainly shows up at the observatory and gazes at the stars.

Mare is so cute! ><b  Originally I didn’t like her that much, but after she started opening up to You, she is absolutely adorable. Then, the epilogue for ***’s route made me feel all warm inside. ><

hm_girl

Subcharacters

There are a lot of subcharacters and their back stories are an important part of the game. As a matter of fact, as you play through each of the routes in the game, you will find out about their past and solve their problems too. The ones you will see the most of are the club leader Okaizumi Haruto-senpai, mysterious club member Suwa Setsuna-senpai, classmate and occult club leader Asuka Mirai, Asuho’s father and cafe owner Souichirou, You and Chinami’s aunt Shino, Komomo/Kosame’s mother and shrine priestess Mayaka and many others who I cannot talk about due to spoilers. I wish there was a route for yousei-san.

Of course, there’s one more heroine, ***. I liked her almost as much as Asuho. Yup, almost as much.

hm_haruto

「ダメ人間...クスクス...」

Overall, I thought that characters were well done. However, since the scenarios were more about resolving problems and less about relationship development, there was not as much development for some characters as I would’ve liked.

Micchi’s character rankings:
Asuho, ***, Mare, Kosame, Chinami, Isuzu, Komomo

Graphics

hm_cg2

The main selling point of Hoshizora is the artwork. They are absolutely stunning. Most of them are at night and are very eyecatching. There is decent variety in the backgrounds for the game. Hoshizora uses a system called Favorite View Point (FVP) where you can zoom up to 2x on any part of the CG. This system is utilized effectively throughout the game to give a greater sense of perspective.

hm_sd

As usual, there are cute SD drawings that pop up every now and then, as well as pictures of various important items. Sometimes, they are animated and the size of the SD varies. Unfortunately, these do not show up in the CG mode.

hm_sd2

System

hm_menu

I like the menu for the game, as well as the system layout. When I first started the game, I spent a few minutes just playing around with the menus. There are 240 save slots plus 12 autosaves. You can also move and copy saved games. There are plenty of settings that you can adjust. The main one to note is the option to skip all or only text that you have read before (default). This is useful when going through the common route on following playthroughs. You can also hide the menu bar at the bottom of the text box.

As usual, there is a CG mode, memory (H scene) mode and sound (bgm/vocals) mode. If you collect all the CGs from a character, it will show as “Complete!”. You can also watch the OP again. As you play the game, various things change in the interface. As you finish more routes, the opening screen changes from daytime to sunset and finally, to nighttime. As you meet new characters, they will show up in the characters options menu where you can modify their speech volume as well as text color.

hm_choices

On following playthroughs, when you reach a choice, it will show you which option increases the relationship points for characters. This is shown with a cute SD sprite.

hm_bustshot_mode

Finishing the game entirely opens up a ‘bustshot mode’, which is essentially a user-controlled viewing of the tachi-e and backgrounds for the game. Fun to play around with.

Sound

There are 47 tracks, including the OP and the 2 EDs. As usual, I like the soft emotional tracks, especially the music box versions. Most of the BGMs fit well in the story, although there are a few that I wouldn’t listen to otherwise. All three of the vocal tracks were quite good. The voice acting for the characters was generally well done, with the exception of Chinami. The difference between her hyper and serious sides is too extreme and the voicing for the H scenes is really bad.

H Scenes

hm_asuho_hcg2

There are between 1 to 3 H scenes for each of the 7 heroines. They’re all relatively short in length with 2-3 positions per scene. Locations were varied, although some were a bit risque. In general, I thought most of them were properly placed and fit in well with the story. However, there were some notable exceptions, such as Isuzu’s first and possibly Kosame’s too. The voice acting for Chinami’s H scenes was the worst I’ve ever heard – she sounded like she was not into it at all. Mare’s H scene gave me flashbacks of Kururi from Flyable Heart. I wholeheartedly loved all of Asuho’s, but that’s probably because I like her character.

Overall

All of Micchi’s reviews will be rated by assigning scores out of 10 to each of the following categories: Scenario, characters, graphics, system, sound, and H scenes. Half marks may be given. The scoring is as follows:

  • 10 – Absolutely satisfied
  • 9 – Among the best, only minor improvements
  • 8 – Good overall
  • 7 – Average, a mix of good and bad
  • 6 – Below average, slightly disappointing
  • <5 – Very disappointed

The overall score is a weighted sum (3x Scenario + 2x Characters + 2x Graphics + 1x System + 1x Sound + 1x H scenes) for a total out of 100.

  • Scenario: 7.5
  • Characters: 8
  • Graphics: 9.5
  • System: 9
  • Sound: 8
  • H Scenes: 7
  • Overall: 81.5

I was quite satisfied with Hoshizora, especially the true end. It brought a smile to my face that just wouldn’t disappear. While the common route was exceedingly long and some routes were extremely short and disappointing, Hoshizora manages to tell a series of romantic stories with plenty of references to astronomy. Having finished it, I have an urge to go stargazing now.

I wish I could see the stars as beautifully as in the game. I also wish for a fandisk.

hm_cg3

私の願い、届いていますか──?

Entry filed under: Reviews. Tags: , , , , .

Spring 2009 Anime – First Impressions Flyable Heart Review

22 Comments Add your own

  • 1. accany  |  April 22, 2009 at 10:33 pm

    Sounds pretty interesting…
    But I hate short stories though and a long common route doesn’t make up for short character routes IMO.
    Art work looks pretty good but it’s not my taste which is the main reason why I didn’t take this up.

    Reply
    • 2. Algester  |  April 23, 2009 at 7:42 pm

      long common route <_< itsusora syndrome…. wait its not even a common route its the prologue <_< mmmmMMM

      Reply
  • 3. Micchi  |  April 23, 2009 at 11:36 am

    @accany: Yes, the common route is long, but the character routes aren’t short with the exception of 2 out of the 7.

    Reply
  • 4. m3rryweather  |  April 24, 2009 at 3:40 pm

    Darn, I need to get along with this one. Asuho is very cute and I really like her. The one route I’m dreading is Chinami. Man, I don’t think I can handle her nonstop jabbering.

    Reply
    • 5. Micchi  |  April 24, 2009 at 3:52 pm

      Yes! Another Asuho fan! Let us join forces! ><b

      Reply
      • 6. mm  |  March 11, 2013 at 5:02 am

        I’m a bit late to the party, but I just had to say that I’m another big Asuho fan! She is just too cute! <3 <3

        One odd thing is that I've gone through Asuho, Isuzu, and Chinami's routes (going through Komomo's currently) and the game CG section doesn't show "Complete" for Asuho. I'm not sure what's up with that as it shows the full page of CGs with none of them hidden. :(

        Thanks for the excellent review.

        Reply
  • 7. Zen  |  April 24, 2009 at 3:56 pm

    Chinami is pretty much the sole reason I did not, and will not touch this game. I do not think I could put up with her for more than five minutes.

    Though the way they explain the various relationships with stars and such irked me as well. The writers could have at least gotten their facts straight.

    Reply
  • 9. yay  |  October 28, 2009 at 1:19 am

    Very good review! I’ve been playing the game but I don’t know but a few words in Japanese, so most of the storyline escaped me. This review clarified a lot.

    I find these untranslated games can be a decent way to pick up some common Japanese phrases and words with the help of a romaji -> hiragana translator and Google translator.

    Reply
    • 10. Micchi  |  October 28, 2009 at 12:31 pm

      Thanks :) Ya, you can learn quite a bit just by exposure. Just keep in mind that it’s generally not formal structure though.

      Reply
  • […] Kogayou work with her through her sheer positiveness. So she’s one of those kinds of people (whom Micchi apparently likes). While she’s the most supportive of Kogayou finding his childhood love, she’s also the […]

    Reply
  • 12. Verbal Rubbish » Blog Archive  |  December 21, 2009 at 4:36 pm

    […] has already placed up a nice review of this game ages ago and for the most part, I agree with it. There’s really nothing more I […]

    Reply
  • […] Hoshizora no Memoria. There’s already two others who have posted reviews long before I have so I’ll throw my own more dramatic and […]

    Reply
  • 14. Unknown  |  November 21, 2010 at 1:08 am

    I can’t find this game anywhere! I really want to download it but every download file i see turned out that i need an acc to use it.

    Reply
  • 15. Jjredster  |  April 19, 2012 at 6:32 pm

    game was great, i’m glad i got to play it translated, i agree with pretty much everything said here in the review to a tee.

    i just hope the fandisc gets translated.

    Reply
  • 16. Reiko  |  April 21, 2012 at 7:16 pm

    My first time playing this and it’s really good. I’m on Asuho’s route and it’s really long. Can’t wait to check out the others. Will follow the order of Micchi’s recommended routes

    Reply
  • 17. Verbal Rubbish » Blog Archive » FAVORITE Addendum  |  May 3, 2012 at 3:37 am

    […] uninformative mini-review of Hoshizora no Memoria can be found here, but a BETTER ONE can be found here. For those wanting a sneak preview of what to expect in Irotoridori no Sekai, there’s also a […]

    Reply
  • 18. destinyz  |  May 12, 2012 at 2:03 pm

    I must agree ****’s route was by far the best,and her story actually felt the most complete to me. Quite a few scenes of hers made feel like crying, or maybe I did (Yeah, I’m a guy who actually cries going through these games). But I do feel that Kosame’s route was actually just behind ****’s. Yes, it was damn short, and overlapped quite a bit with Komomo’s, but I really enjoyed it with going through her story. Unlike most other who played the game though, I wasn’t particularly fond of Asuho. Nothing’s wrong with her,maybe it was just something in me subconsciously rejecting her. Regardless of thoughts, I felt that this is a game very much worth playing, and well, not completely on par with some of my favorites (G-Senjou no Maou comes to mind, even though they are very different games), but the majority of the people playing will enjoy it like I did.

    ps. The opening “Eternal recurrence” was awesome on many levels.

    Reply
  • 19. Alexis Becarre  |  June 12, 2012 at 10:04 pm

    Nice review but there is something that’s not right about your notations.

    •7 – Average, a mix of good and bad
    •6 – Below average, slightly disappointing

    You’re way too nice, because mathematically, the average of 10 is 5. And below average is 4.

    Reply
    • 20. Micchi  |  June 12, 2012 at 11:23 pm

      Yes, I’m using an uneven scale. I don’t really like giving scores of under 5 unless it’s really bad, so that’s why the mean is skewed upwards. Just a personal preference. Also means that most scores will mostly be around 70.

      Reply
  • 21. Arekusanda  |  September 29, 2012 at 12:52 pm

    Thank you really much for this helpfull review :3 I never used to understand why ppl would write those until i started playing VN >_<
    Your reviews really help me decide on novels, they're really useful to me :3
    *bows twice*
    And by the way.. Asuho! <3 xD
    And for criticisim.. I don't see anything in these reviews that needs to get better, so many nice features like a good system for ranking the VN's overall value, character playthrough rankings.. Even if it's just your opinion it's helpful, that's what makes it good.

    Reply
  • 22. NiReic  |  May 20, 2014 at 6:35 am

    For You’s picture you could use his picture from the Backlog. Also, love this game even though I’m not that far into my first route (still haven’t been hit by the scythe)

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


おかえりお兄ちゃん、お姉ちゃん!

Recent News


Webclap

Thank you, nii-san!

Latest Entries

Categories

いつでもスーパー妹タイム

Authors

Micchi

Imouto sensor ON
二次元妹は至高

nemuiwanko

Building up my nendoroid army

Zen

. . .

Upcoming Eroge

Last updated: 12/05

12/22
AstralAir no Shiroki Towa Finale
アストラエアの白き永遠 Finale -白き星の夢- 応援中!! Hoshifuru Yoru no Farnese
星降る夜のファルネーゼ応援中! Liber_7
Ryuukishi Bloody†Saga
『竜騎士 Bloody†Saga』を応援しています! Meguru Sekai de Towa Naru Chikai o!
スタジオエゴ最新作「廻るセカイで永遠なるチカイを!」情報公開中! Hakui no Tenshi wa Osewazuki
白衣の天使 応援バナー Zannen na Ane to no Love Comedy
残念な姉との幸福論(ラブコメディー) 応援中! Yuusei Tenshi Primaveil Drei Dark Mission
『遊聖天使プリマヴェールDrei ダークミッション』応援中! VenusBlood -RAGNAROK-
Zettai Junshu☆New Kozukuri World
Love Love Sisters
Shinsou Noise
Himekoi*Sucreine!
Amakano+
Amenity's Life
Hatsukoi Sankaime
Maji de Watashi ni Koi Shinasai! A
Honoguraki Toki no Hate Yori
Ou no Mimi ni wa Todokanai!
Akiyume Kukuru
Hoshizora Tea Party Extra
BALDR HEART EXE
Koi wa Yumemiru Mouretsu Girl!
12/29
Harmonia
01/27
Kanojo to Ore to Lovely Day
『彼女と俺の恋愛日常』応援中です! Hoshikoi*Tinkle
きゃべつそふと第一弾「星恋*ティンクル」応援中! Ninki Seiyuu no Tsukurikata
『人気声優のつくりかた』 Real Eroge Situation!
自宅すたじお 2nd Project『リアルエロゲシチュエーション!(リアエロ)』応援中! Fu'un to Kou'un to Koi Uranai no Tarot
『不運と幸運と恋占いのタロット』応援中! Silverio Trinity
『シルヴァリオ トリニティ』応援中! Mamono Musume no Sodatekata
Kimi no Hitomi ni Hit Me
Bitch Shimai ga Seijun na Hazu ga Nai!!
Kami-sama no Game
Ojou-sama wa Iinari Mitai Desu!?
Chiccha na Hanayome
Hi no Nai Tokoro ni Kemuri wa Tatanai
Tsukikage no Simulacre
Aikagi
Lamune 2
02/24
Ouka Sabaki
Ojou-sama no Hanbun wa Renai de Dekiteimasu!
Serufure
Onii-chan, Kiss no Junbi wa Mada Desu ka? FD
Tantei Seven
Shugaten!
Suisei Ginka
Noroi no Maken ni Yamitsuki Otome
Office ni Sasou Ecchi na Kanojo
03/24
Natsuiro Kokoro Log FD
Hearts『ナツイロココロログ Happy Summer』応援中です! Haruru Minamo ni
【はるるみなもに!】情報ページ公開中! Kamidanomi Shisugite Ore no Mirai ga Yabai.
HULOTTE『神頼みしすぎて俺の未来がヤバい。』 Haruoto Alice*Gram
Nanawind第四弾「春音*アリスグラム」応援中! Koinosu☆Ichacolize
Majo to Tsurugi to Sen no Tsuki
Hataraku Otaku no Ren'ai Jijou
Omoi o Sasageru Otome no Melody
Amanatsu Adolescence
03/31
Chrono Box
TRINOLINE
04/28
D.S. i.F.
D.S.i.F. -Dal Segno- in Future Ao no Kanata no Four Rhythm EXTRA1
Grisaia: Phantom Trigger Vol. 1
Grisaia: Phantom Trigger Vol. 2
Tayutama 2 FD
Niizuma LOVELY×CATION
05/26
Anata ni Koisuru Ren'ai Recette
Recently announced
Chuuni Hime no Teikoku
Omokage Railback
Bokura no Sekai ni Shukufuku o.
Hitotsu no Yane no, Tsubasa no Shita de
Alice Muppet
Momoiro Guardian EX
kano-tsuku
Rance 10
Shin Koihime†Musou -Kakumei-
Yume to Iro de Dekiteiru
Randoseru Syndrome
Aoiro Note
Saihate★Frontier
Ama no Shoujo
Toki*Sora
Pure Marriage Sakura-hen
Pure Marriage Serika-hen
MIBURO
Bishoujo Mangekyou: Tsumi to Batsu no Shoujo
Ao no Kanata no Four Rhythm -ZWEI-
Tsukihime Remake
Majo to Ken to Sen no Tsuki
Renai Kyoushitsu
Iyashi no Megami no Marmot
Lost Echoes
Nora to Oujo to Noraneko Heart 2
nine -Episode 1-
Ojou-sama to Aware na Ko
Onii-chan Daisuki!
Tonari no Shoujo
Full Kiss
Newton to Ringo no Ki
Golden Hour
DependSpace DESERT RAIN FiNALIoN Gamer's Square Getchu.com りぺあ ~Patch Library~ かめのこおらの休憩所 愚者の館 新:誠也の部屋 萌えゲーアワード
からふる ぱれっとx365 Indico lite KOGE*2 HOUSE moeyo.com MOON PHASE 雑記 インターネットラジオステーション<音泉> Steparu.com

Feeds

Thank you for visiting!

  • 4,052,081 hits since Sept 2/08


%d bloggers like this: